Text message (SMS) codes are better than no multifactor authentication, but they’re the weakest common option. An authenticator app with number matching is a solid default for most employees. Passkeys and hardware security keys are the strongest because they resist phishing, so use them for administrators, finance staff and executives first.
A few years ago the conversation was simply “turn on MFA.” That’s still the most important step, and it blocks a huge share of account takeovers. But attackers have adapted. They now intercept text messages, trick people into reading codes over the phone and set up fake login pages that pass the code straight through to the real site. So the question for small businesses around Dallas-Fort Worth has shifted from whether to use MFA to which kind.
What are the main types of MFA?
| Method | How it works | Phishing resistant? | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| SMS or voice code | A code is texted or read to your phone | No | A last resort or fallback |
| Authenticator app code | A six-digit code that changes every 30 seconds | No | Accounts that don’t support push or passkeys |
| Authenticator app push with number matching | You approve a sign-in and type the number shown on screen | Partly | Most employees |
| Passkey | Your phone or computer signs in using a cryptographic key, unlocked by face, fingerprint or PIN | Yes | Admins, finance, executives and increasingly everyone |
| Hardware security key | A physical USB or NFC key you tap to sign in | Yes | Global admins and emergency accounts |
Is SMS MFA safe?
It’s safer than a password alone, but it has real weaknesses. Text messages aren’t encrypted, and in December 2024 CISA’s mobile communications guidance warned that “a threat actor with access to a telecommunication provider’s network who intercepts these messages can read them.” Attackers also use SIM swapping, where they talk a mobile carrier into moving your number to their phone. And a convincing phone call or fake login page can get someone to hand over the code.
NIST’s updated digital identity guidelines, finalized in August 2025, label phone-network codes as a “restricted” authenticator and require services to offer at least one phishing-resistant option. In plain terms, SMS is acceptable as a fallback, not as your main line of defense.
Why did Microsoft urge people to stop using phone-based MFA?
Microsoft has been steering customers away from SMS and voice calls for years for the reasons above, and toward app-based and passwordless sign-in. In May 2025 it went further for consumer accounts, making new Microsoft accounts passwordless by default and encouraging passkeys instead. In Microsoft 365 for business, administrators can choose which methods are allowed, require number matching in Microsoft Authenticator and roll out passkeys through Microsoft Entra.
Is an authenticator app better than SMS?
Yes. Authenticator apps like Microsoft Authenticator aren’t tied to your phone number, so SIM swapping doesn’t help an attacker. Push notifications with number matching also stop “MFA fatigue” attacks, where someone spams approval requests hoping you’ll tap yes to make them stop. CISA’s guidance is honest about the limit, though. It notes that authenticator codes “are better than SMS, they are still vulnerable to phishing.” A fake login page can still relay a code or approval in real time.
What is a passkey, and why is it more secure?
A passkey replaces the password with a cryptographic key stored on your phone, computer or security key. You unlock it with your face, fingerprint or device PIN. The key only works on the real website it was created for, so a look-alike phishing page simply can’t use it. There’s also no code to read aloud and nothing to type into the wrong place.
For users, passkeys are often easier than passwords. For businesses, they’re the most practical way to get phishing-resistant sign-in without handing everyone a USB key. Our guide on how to spot a phishing email explains why that resistance matters so much.
Can attackers bypass MFA?
Sometimes, which is exactly why the type matters. The most common bypasses are social: a fake help desk call asking someone to read back a code, a flood of push requests late at night or a phishing page that relays your sign-in to the real site and steals the session that follows. None of those make MFA pointless. They make weak MFA easier to get around. Number matching shuts down push fatigue. Passkeys and security keys shut down relay phishing because they won’t work on the wrong website. And good sign-in policies, such as blocking risky locations or requiring a managed device, add another layer. For employees who work from home or travel, our remote and hybrid work security checklist covers the rest of the picture.
Which MFA method should your business use?
- Global admins and emergency accounts: hardware security keys (FIDO2). Microsoft recommends them for emergency access accounts, as we cover in what happens if the only person with your admin passwords leaves.
- Finance, payroll, HR and executives: passkeys or security keys. These are the people attackers target for wire fraud.
- Everyone else: Microsoft Authenticator with number matching now, with a plan to move to passkeys.
- SMS: only as a temporary fallback during rollout or for systems that offer nothing better.
MFA works best alongside good passwords, not instead of them. Our business password policy guide covers the other half.
How do you roll out stronger MFA without a revolt?
Start with the people who have the most access, explain why in plain terms and schedule short setup sessions instead of sending a link and hoping. Register at least two methods per person so a lost phone isn’t a lockout. Have a clear process for verifying identity before resetting MFA, because help desk impersonation is a favorite trick. And in Microsoft 365, use authentication strength policies so admins can only sign in with phishing-resistant methods.
Frequently asked questions
Is SMS two-factor authentication safe?
It’s better than a password alone, but it’s the weakest common MFA method. Text messages can be intercepted or redirected through SIM swapping, and codes can be phished. Use an authenticator app or passkey when possible.
What is the most secure type of MFA?
Phishing-resistant methods are the most secure, specifically passkeys and FIDO2 hardware security keys. They only work on the legitimate website, so fake login pages can’t capture them.
Is Microsoft Authenticator better than text messages?
Yes. It isn’t tied to your phone number, and push approvals with number matching block MFA fatigue attacks. It can still be phished, so passkeys are the next step up.
What is a passkey?
A passkey is a sign-in credential stored on your device and unlocked with your face, fingerprint or PIN. It replaces the password and can’t be used on fake websites.
Should small businesses use hardware security keys?
At least for administrator and emergency accounts. For most employees, passkeys on their phones or computers offer similar phishing resistance with less hardware to manage.
How The Fulcrum Group helps
We help North Texas organizations move from “we turned on MFA” to MFA that actually holds up. Through SPOT Managed Security Services, that includes reviewing the methods you allow, enabling number matching, rolling out passkeys and security keys for high-risk roles, setting admin sign-in policies and helping staff through setup without the drama.
If you’re not sure which MFA your team is really using, Schedule a Discovery Call.

